Let's Talk with Lois Winston
A Cat, a Dog, and a Parrot Walk into a Cozy Mystery
With apologies to Jane Austen, it’s a truth (nearly) universally acknowledged, that cozy mystery sleuths should be in possession of at least one pet. Usually, but not exclusively, a cat or dog. And if the cat or dog possesses abilities that aid the sleuth in figuring out whodunit, all the better.
I once read a book about an unlikable woman who died suddenly and came back as a crime-solving dog. (Here’s where you picture me doing an eye roll.) Although I can buy into a well-written time-travel and do love me a good Star Wars or Marvel movie (stressing good here), I draw the line at people being reincarnated as sentient animals. Feel free to disagree, but I’m too much of a realist to suspend disbelief that much (says the woman who has no problem with Iron Man, the Hulk, or Thor!)
However, I’ve seen plenty of instances in real life where pets have been instrumental in coming to the rescue. The nightly news often showcases dogs who have found people lost for days or even weeks in the wilderness or buried under the ruble of a natural disaster. Researchers are discovering that cats can sense some cancers in people prior to symptoms showing up. Parrots have “testified” in court cases.
When I first set out to write my Anastasia Pollack Crafting Mystery series, I knew I should include a pet, but I wanted neither a placid one used only as window dressing nor one that readers would have a hard time believing. Cozy readers suspend disbelief enough in accepting amateur sleuths who not only solve cases faster than law enforcement but stumble across more dead bodies than the average homicide detective during an entire career.
Since I was writing a humorous series, I not only wanted the non-human inhabitants of Anastasia’s world to reflect that humor, but I also wanted them to be characters in their own right, while still being believable pets.
In my series, Anastasia is saddled with her communist mother-in-law, a woman who has never had a kind word for her. Her multi-married mother, who often moves into Anastasia’s home when between husbands, claims to descend from Russian nobility. The two women get along…well, like cats and dogs. So, I gave Anastasia’s mother a corpulent white Persian cat named Catherine the Great and gave her mother-in-law a French bulldog named Manifesto (after the communist treatise.) Catherine the Great and Manifesto get along as well as their owners. I live by the motto that zany characters + conflict = humor.
I wasn’t done, though. Years ago, I read a memoir about a family who had owned an African Grey parrot, a species known for its intelligence and amazing language skills. I decided Anastasia would inherit Ralph, an African Grey, from her great-aunt, a Shakespearean scholar and professor. Because Ralph spent most of his life in classrooms and lecture halls, he’s developed an uncanny knack for squawking situation-appropriate quotes from the Bard of Avon.
However, as I previously mentioned, I didn’t want pets as window dressing to the series. The pets in my books not only provide comic relief, but they’ve also become integral to many of the plots in the series—while still being believable pets. As such, both Manifesto and Ralph have saved Anastasia on more than one occasion.
As for Catherine the Great, so far, she’s content to ignore the foibles of the humans in her life. She’d rather spend her days grooming herself, eating, and sleeping—not necessarily in that order. She does a lot of all three. However, some day, she may find herself in a situation where she’s called upon to act, and I have no doubt she’ll be up to the challenge. After all, I’m the author, and her fate is in my hands.
How do you feel about pets in cozies? Are you in the “Yes, please! Always a Pet” camp? Or don’t you care as long as the book is well-written with engaging characters and a great mystery? Post a comment for a chance to win a promo code for a free audiobook of one of the first 10 Anastasia Pollack Crafting Mysteries.
Our July contest is closed, but the August contest will open on August 1. Be sure and check back to enter the two-book giveaway.
Want to learn more about author Lois Winston? Visit her WEBSITE
Posted in Let's Talk, with Lois Winston • Tags: A Cat, a Dog, Anastasia Pollack Crafting Mysteries, and a Parrot Walk into a Cozy Mystery, Let's Talk, Lois Winston, Pets in mysteries | 23 Comments
If it is an engaging book, it doesn’t have to have a pet. I think it makes the character more relatable if there is a pet since I have always had pets.
Thanks for stopping by and commenting, Jeanne. I think many pet owners will share your opinion.
I love meeting unusual pets in cozy mysteries. I’ll never own another one, so a good book lets me pretend I have them for a little while.
Cheryl, with my allergies, all my pets are reside in the pages of my books.
Love pets in cozies but please please don’t kill them off
Never, Crystal! They will live within the pages of my books forever.
I love pets in cozies – as long as the cozy is well-written!
Absolutely, Shannon! I couldn’t agree more! There’s no point wasting precious reading time on a book that isn’t well-written.
Always thought I’d never put a pet I’m a book, but then I realized it was a trope that readers would miss. Therefore, in the Sarah Blair series, I went with the concept of a realistic cat followed by a realistic rescue dog. I’ve always enjoyed your pets because the cat and dog had conflict and tension, but in a humorous manner, and Ralph’s comments are so on point (and you drop them in just enough and at the right times).
Debra, sending you a huge cyber hug for your lovely comments! You brightened my morning!
I’m probably in the minority, but as long as the book is written well, I don’t care one way or the other about pets in a mystery. While they can be entertaining, so often they seem contrived and too over-the-top for my taste.
Most cozy readers seem to expect them, though, Terry. I know one author whose publisher stuck a cat on the cover of one of her books, even though there was no cat in the book. When the author complained, the editor said it was because cozy readers buy books with cats. Meanwhile, the author got lots of negative reviews from people who bought the book expecting a cat to be in it and were disappointed.
As a dog and cat lover, and an author who has series featuring sleuthing dogs and cats, of course I approve of pets in cozies! BUT…nothing worse than a pet on the cover and no pet in the book (or, as you said, if said pet is only used for window dressing).
See my reply above to Terry, Diane. 😉
I love pets in cozies, probably because, since I was a child, I have always had a pet. Although I like cats best in mysteries any kind of pet will do!
Thanks for stopping by to comment, Helen. How do you feel about talking parrots? 😉
I am definitely in the yes please category. I think pets add something extra to the story and makes the main character feel more relatable since they are also a pet lover.
Thanks for joining in the discussion, Cherie!
While writing the first book in the Detective Parrott series, I wanted to give Parrott a pet. Not a dog, because he was gone long hours from home. Not a cat, because he’s allergic. So I settled on a cockatiel named Horace. Also very smart, Horace acts like a Greek chorus, commenting on action. I never dreamed Horace would become a scene-stealer, but he has!
Gee, Saralyn, why not a parrot for Parrott? ;-D
I don’t care if there is or isn’t a pet in a mystery. I’m not fond of talking animals, but I do believe they can sense things we can’t. Otherwise, it’s fine with me if a pet acts like a normal dog or cat. Their antics can be humorous enough.
Thanks, Nancy!
I love pets in all books, because how the characters relates to pets shows a great deal about that character.